Order Now

Our Story

Baked in Heaven is an online bakery specializing in mega-stuffed cookies. We are based out of Westchester, NY and serve dessert lovers nationwide!

For founder Hannah Bander, baking sweet treats has always been a hobby, but in March 2021, Hannah, along with her boyfriend of over three years, Jonathan Goncher, decided to take the leap and turn a life-long passion into a business.

We hope everyone enjoys our heavenly mega-stuffed cookies!

Our MegaStuffed Cookies

Cookies & Cream Heaven

Vanilla base cookie filled with crushed Oreo’s, white chocolate chips, and stuffed with our homemade cookies n cream buttercream, topped with white chocolate drip and a whole Oreo

Circus Heaven

Vanilla base cookie mixed with circus cookies, golden Oreos, white chocolate chips, stuffed with pink vanilla buttercream, topped with white chocolate drip and a circus animal cookie

Cinnamon Heaven

Vanilla base cookie filled with our homemade cinnamon roll spread and Cinnamon Toast Crunch, stuffed with our homemade cream cheese buttercream, topped with white chocolate drip and a brown sugar toaster pastry

S'Mores Heaven

Chocolate base cookie filled with Golden Grahams cereal, milk chocolate chips, stuffed with marshmallow fluff, topped with chocolate drip, and a toasted marshmallow

Slutty Brownie Heaven

Chocolate base cookie mixed with chocolate chip cookies and Oreos, stuffed with edible chocolate chip cookie dough, topped with chocolate drip and a homemade slutty brownie

Peanut Butter Heaven

Chocolate base cookie filled with peanut butter chips, milk chocolate chips, stuffed with peanut butter, topped with chocolate drip, and a mini Reese’s PB cup

Rainbow Heaven

Chocolate chip cookie base stuffed with a rainbow cookie, topped with chocolate drip, and another rainbow cookie

Cookie Monster Heaven

Blue velvet cookie base mixed with milk chocolate chips, white chocolate chips, Oreo’s, chocolate chip cookie. It is then stuffed with a whole Oreo and a chocolate chip cookie, and topped with chocolate drip and a chips ahoy

Red Velvet Heaven

Red velvet cookie base mixed with white chocolate chips, stuffed with cream cheese buttercream, topped with white chocolate drip and red velvet crumb

Birthday Heaven

Funfetti cookie base mixed with sprinkles and white chocolate chips, stuffed with vanilla buttercream, topped with white chocolate drip and a homemade birthday cake

Cookie Butter Heaven

Brown sugar cookie base mixed with cookie biscuits and white chocolate chips, stuffed with cookie butter, topped with white chocolate drip and a cookie biscuit

Cosmic Brownie Heaven

Chocolate cookie base mixed with rainbow sprinkles and chocolate chips, stuffed with chocolate buttercream, topped with chocolate drip and a Cosmic Brownie

Maple Latte Heaven

Maple base cookie stuffed with java chip Oreos and white chocolate chips, stuffed with espresso buttercream, topped with white chocolate drip, a mini crumb cake, and a maple syrup pipette

Apple Pie Heaven

Cinnamon spice cookie base mixed with apple fritter Poptarts and white chocolate chips, stuffed with apple compote, topped with white chocolate drip and a mini apple pie slice 

Pumpkin Cheesecake Heaven

Pumpkin spice cookie base mixed with white chocolate chips and pumpkin spice Oreos, stuffed with cream cheese buttercream, topped with white chocolate drip and a pumpkin spice sandwich cookie